zavvy logo
Solutions
Onboarding
& Preboarding
Preboarding
Close the gap between signing and start
Onboarding
Wow new hires without getting lost in busywork
Event Scheduling
Automatically manage your orientation events
Development
& Skills
Career Frameworks
Create role clarity with transparent career pathways
Growth Plans
Combine goals with measurable action
Skills Matrix
Understand everyone's strengths and opportunities
Training
& Knowledge
Learning Management
Create and manage engaging courses
Training Library
Find the right resource for everyone
Power Skills
Find expert-led, high impact training programs
Performance
& Feedback
Performance Reviews
Measure performance without the bias and act
360° Feedback
Run any kind of feedback process
1:1s
Align people managers and reports through structure
Engagement
& Insights
Engagement Surveys
Understand your people and engage with precision
Connection Programs
Strengthen relationships with regular meetups

Platform

|

Consultation

|

Integrations
Customers
Templates
JourneysFeedbackTraining Library
IntegrationsPricing
HR Insights
BlogCommunityTemplates & PlaybooksReal-life HR Examples
Login
EN
EnglishDeutsch
LoginLogin
See it in action
Login
Settings and language
Language
EnglishDeutschSign in
Login
Try for freeGet a demo
zavvy logo
Lösungen
Onboarding
& Preboarding
Preboarding
Schon vor Tag 1 begeistern
Onboarding
Schneller und besser einarbeiten
Meetings
Onboarding-Events ganz automatisch managen
Entwicklung
& Skills
Karriere-Frameworks
Klare Karrierepfade für alle anbieten
Entwicklungspläne
Ziele mit messbaren Maßnahmen verbinden
Kompetenzmatrix
Mit tiefen Insights Potenziale aufdecken
Training
& Wissen
Learning Management
Effiziente Trainings per Drag-and-Drop erstellen
Externe Trainings
Die richtigen Ressourcen immer griffbereit
Power Skills
Intensivtrainings für die wichtigsten Skills
Performance
& Feedback
Performance Reviews
Leistung fair und transparent beurteilen
360° Feedback
Feedbackkultur nach Ihren Wünschen schaffen
1:1s
Produktivere Meetings für alle ermöglichen
Engagement
& Insights
Engagement Umfragen
Bedürfnisse verstehen und gezielt erfüllen
Meetup-Rituale
Beziehungen durch regelmäßige Meetings stärken

Plattform

|

Beratung

|

Integrationen
Referenzen
Vorlagen
JourneysFeedbackTrainingsbibliothek
Preise
HR Wissen
BlogCommunityVorlagen & PlaybooksReal-life HR Examples
Login
EN
EnglishDeutsch
LoginLogin
See it in action
Login
Settings and language
Sprache
EnglishDeutschLogin
Login
Kostenlos testenDemo vereinbaren

zavvy logo
Solutions
Onboarding
& Preboarding
Preboarding
Close the gap between signing and start
Onboarding
Wow new hires without getting lost in busywork
Event Scheduling
Automatically manage your orientation events
Development
& Skills
Career Frameworks
Create role clarity with transparent career pathways
Growth Plans
Combine goals with measurable action
Skills Matrix
Understand everyone's strengths and opportunities
Training
& Knowledge
Learning Management
Create and manage engaging courses
Training Library
Find the right resource for everyone
Power Skills
Find expert-led, high impact training programs
Performance
& Feedback
Performance Reviews
Measure performance without the bias and act
360° Feedback
Run any kind of feedback process
1:1s
Align people managers and reports through structure
Engagement
& Insights
Engagement Surveys
Understand your people and engage with precision
Connection Programs
Strengthen relationships with regular meetups

Platform

|

Consultation

|

Integrations
Customers
Templates
JourneysFeedbackTraining Library
IntegrationsPricing
HR Insights
BlogCommunityTemplates & PlaybooksReal-life HR Examples
Login
EN
EnglishDeutsch
LoginLogin
See it in action
Login
Settings and language
Language
EnglishDeutschSign in
Login
Try for freeGet a demo
Navigation
Quicklinks
‍
  • 🔍 360 feedback vs. performance review: What’s the difference?
  • 🆚 Pros & cons of 360 feedback vs. performance appraisals
  • 🙅 5 Downsides of performance review
  • ➡️ Move to ongoing feedback with Zavvy

360 Feedback vs. Performance Appraisal Systems: Which Is the Best?

Zuletzt aktualisiert:
14.10.2022
Lesezeit:
8 minutes
Last updated:
October 14, 2022
Time to read:
8 minutes
Understand the differences between 360-degree feedback performance appraisal systems and the value that each can bring to your workforce.

There's no better way to illustrate the 360 feedback vs. performance appraisal debate than by looking at a company like General Electric. 

Led by CEO Jack Welch from 1981 to 2001, GE was famed for its "rank and yank" performance reviews. They involved scoring individual employee performances each year and firing the bottom 10% who hadn't hit the mark. 

Under the new leadership of Jeff Immelt, GE rolled out its new performance appraisal system in 2016, switching to an agile and feedback-driven culture with more frequent check-ins. Susan Peters, GE's Head of Human Resources, explained the company's performance management pivot to Quartz: 

"The world isn't really on an annual cycle anymore for anything. I think some of it is millennial-based. It's the way millennials are used to working and getting feedback, which is more frequent, faster, mobile-enabled, so there were multiple drivers that said it's time to make this big change."

If you're intrigued by the differences between 360-degree feedback, and a more traditional performance assessment system, this guide will break down the value of each.

🔍 360 feedback vs. performance review: What is the difference?

If you're new to performance management terms, we'll start with a question you've probably been scratching your head over. What's the difference between 360 feedback vs. performance reviews? 

What is a performance review? 

A performance review is a process where a manager retrospectively evaluates an employee's work performance. The evaluation covers a set period, usually six to twelve months.

What is a performance review? 

The performance review process often includes:

  • A review of the employee goals, objectives, and KPIs;
  • A discussion of the employee's successes and challenges;
  • A review of the manager's feedback;
  • A performance rating or score;
  • An action plan for the next review period.

What is 360 feedback? 

360-degree feedback is a performance management process in which employees give and receive a wide variety of multi-directional feedback, including: 

  • Upward feedback from an employee to a manager; 
  • Downward feedback from a manager to their direct report;
  • Peer-based feedback from team members or colleagues from adjacent teams;
  • Self-appraisals by the reviewee.
What is 360 feedback?

This model is more accurate as it provides redirecting and reinforcing feedback from a wider group of people who see the employee in different contexts. Plus, employees can receive feedback on predetermined competencies or skills more frequently than a traditional appraisal. 

Some see 360 feedback as more casual than an annual appraisal. However, it still uses a formal structure and links to development plans to drive growth.

360 feedback via Zavvy
360 feedback via Zavvy
360 feedback form template

What's the purpose of measuring performance with an appraisal or 360 feedback? 

All companies have business goals and objectives to hit, and measuring individual performances is one way to ensure we meet these goals. Feedback and employee appraisals are the perfect performance metrics, as they calibrate whether an employee is on track and highlight any improvement areas. 

For example, an employee aims to increase sales by 10% in the next quarter. 360 feedback identifies whether this target is realistic and whether the employee has reached it. It also pinpoints the next steps, including training and further support such as mentoring and setting new employee goals. 

➡️ Check out our guide to improving performance management for a deeper look into driving a culture of growth. 
"It's no secret that the traditional performance management system is broken. Countless studies have shown that the annual performance review is ineffective at improving employee performance and engagement. In fact, many employees find the process to be stressful and anxiety-inducing.

360 feedback is a more holistic approach to performance management that considers input from an employee's peers, direct reports, and managers. This type of feedback: 

- Provides a well-rounded view of an employee's strengths. 
- Highlights areas for improvement and can provide a forum for discussing how to address those areas.
- Can be an effective way to improve communication and collaboration within an organization." Jennifer Hartman, Human Resources Expert, Fit Small Business.

🆚 Pros & cons of 360 feedback vs. performance appraisals

Let's break down the pros and cons of how 360 feedback fares compared to performance appraisals in terms of these top HR concerns.

Bias 

Feedback bias is a common issue in formal reviews, with 188 different unconscious biases that could creep up. 

The content of annual appraisals can be misleading and inaccurate due to some of the following types of bias:

  • Recency bias - if you hold appraisals on an annual basis, a reviewer might only recall information that happened directly before the review rather than a project that concluded 11 months ago. 
  • Ageism, gender bias, or racial bias - a single reviewer holds a traditional performance appraisal, and their individual biases can skew the results. 
  • Halo effect - a manager might judge an all-star performer on an area they shine in rather than being given a well-rounded evaluation of their actual performance. 
Tip: Frequent feedback from various sources can stamp out some of these biases, whether intentional or unconscious. 

Employee engagement 

Performance appraisals are often a one-way conversation where the manager tells employees what they did well and what needs improvement. 

But if an employee is already disengaged, an annual performance review can be the final straw, thus creating a negative feedback loop.

Alternatively, 360-degree reviews go beyond delivering employee feedback and openly surveys the workforce to gather opinions that will drive company success. The goal is to close the feedback loop and use data to improve employee engagement.

And the results speak volumes. Companies that seek and act on employee feedback via 360 reviews have 40% higher engagement rates compared to companies that don't invest in this area, according to a Qualtrics report. 

Team relationships 

While annual performance appraisals can strain the manager-employee relationship, 360 feedback opens up the floor to get input from an employee's entire team. This can improve communication and collaboration within an organization.

Employees who receive feedback from their peers are more likely to trust their coworkers and feel like they're part of a team. And when employees feel like they're part of a team, they excel in their roles. 

Forbes' "3 Ways to Create Value in Team Coaching" describes the amazing results of creating a trust-based team using 360-degree feedback at the heart of its communication. 

Real-time insights

One of the main criticisms of traditional performance reviews is they take place through the rear-view mirror. By the time an employee sits down with their manager, the situation has already passed, and it's too late to change the course of events.

But late reporting isn't an issue with the continuous nature of 360-degree feedback. Employees can address issues as they're happening. And managers can give real-time feedback that can improve an employee's performance.

Tip: Fast course correction is the beauty of having an always-on feedback system. It's not about catching someone doing something wrong; it's about encouraging the behaviors that will help an employee - and your business - succeed.

Employee motivation 

If you're looking for the ultimate way to motivate your employees, then regular conversations and ongoing coaching hold the key to success. The numbers below don't lie: 

  • 60% of employees desire daily or weekly feedback.
  • 80% of employees want to receive feedback on-the-spot rather than during an annual performance appraisal. (HR Dive)
  • 89% of HR leaders believe that continuous peer feedback produces successful outcomes. (Forbes)
Employee Feedback Statistics

Employees crave continuous constructive feedback to power their career development. Companies that want their workforce to stay motivated must decide the most valuable type of feedback to provide. Crucially, the feedback should be actionable. 

💡 Follow these feedback best practices to get the most out of your 360 review cycles. 

Impact on staff turnover 

Employees who stay with a company do so because they feel part of something. Bidirectional feedback allows them to have their voices heard and feel motivated in their roles.

The lack of opportunity to improve is one of the main reasons employees leave companies. Still, companies have the option to turn this around. 

Jonathan Franchell, CEO of Ironpaper and Forbes Council Member, says: 

"Companies can take the easy road — letting employee X go, chalking up them leaving to the Great Resignation. Instead, the hard thing to do is get feedback from those who leave and those who stay. Take that feedback and begin change."

Ease of implementation 

One of the greatest misconceptions about 360 feedback cycles is that they're hard to implement. After all, providing regular check-ins with staff sounds means extra work.

Wrong. When done right, 360 feedback can save you time. You no longer need to wait until an annual performance review to improve the performance of each team member. Instead, regular feedback will respond to current performance, allowing you to course-correct to drive future performance. 

We recommend using a 360 feedback tool to automate employee feedback so it runs seamlessly in the background. This way, you can focus on more important things — like smashing your business objectives!

🆘 If setting up your first review cycle sounds daunting, you can't go wrong with a 360-degree feedback template. 
360 feedback form template

‍

🙅 5 Performance review downsides

Traditional performance reviews come with several downsides to avoid. Here are some of the main ones:

5 Performance Review Downsides

1. Appraisals can be paper-heavy 

The beauty of moving to feedback software is that your feedback systems are digitized and automated. This way, you can avoid the paper-heavy process of performance appraisals, where managers lose track of documents and have to go through the laborious task of filling out endless worksheets. 

2. Appraisals rely on memory

Formal performance reviews are the most unreliable as they cover outdated events that a manager may or may not recall correctly. As a result, employees may feel frustrated because this doesn't accurately represent their performance.

3. Reviews can foster a negative environment

Performance appraisals can often be a chance for managers to vent their frustrations with an employee. Unfortunately, this can lead to a negative environment where employees feel belittled rather than motivated. 

While redirecting feedback does serve a purpose when dealing with performance issues, it's essential to use it strategically. Avoid making redirecting feedback the main focus of your performance feedback cycles. 

4. Traditional reviews don't always encourage positive change

If employees are constantly told they need to improve in the same area, they're likely to become discouraged. And if their manager isn't providing any solutions, they won't know how to make the changes required. This is where bidirectional feedback comes in, as it offers a more positive and proactive way to encourage change. 

5. Appraisals can lack accountability 

Appraisals can be confusing. Even when a manager and employee have agreed on performance goals for the year ahead, who is responsible for ensuring the employee hits the targets? 

Will the manager be accountable for providing adequate training and being available to mentor throughout the year? 

Or is the employee accountable for finding their path? 

➡️ Move to ongoing feedback with Zavvy

If you have to choose one over the other, then it's clear that continuous 360 feedback is the way of the future. 

However, there's a strong case for traditional performance reviews coexisting alongside continuous feedback as long as they tie to an employee's growth and development plan.
Role Cards-Feedback-Growth Plans via Zavvy
Role Cards-Feedback-Growth Plans via Zavvy

With actionable insights, employees will know how to gain more skills and knowledge and improve their performance.

Zavvy's 360 review software enables companies like yours to implement a forward-thinking data-driven feedback system at the click of a button. Our performance management software will save you hours running processes, including: 

  • Employee development check-ins;
  • Performance reviews;
  • Monthly 1:1 meetings;
  • Remote engagement surveys;
  • Team-level feedback; 
  • Leadership development surveys.
And it all runs in the flow of work! Schedule a demo to learn more.
development plan spreadsheet template download
Employee onboarding software bannerLearning management system EN360 Grad Feedback BannerEnablement ENEnablement ENPeople development software
Mitarbeiter Onboarding Software Zavvy Bannerlearning management system 
Mitarbeiter Enablement Software
Enablement ENTalent Management Software
Keke Kaikhosroshvili
Keke Kaikhosroshvili

Keke is Zavvy's expert in learning experience. On our blog, she shares experience and insights based on her studies in learning design and experiences made with our customers.

Linkedin LogoMedium Logo

Read next

Als Nächstes lesen

How Avi Medical trains their staff in the flow of work with scenario-based, blended, and micro learning
Creating a training routine for leaders at Freeletics
How Y-Combinator-Backed Awesomic Gets Their Top-Notch Designers Up To Speed
How DataGuard Runs Hybrid Onboarding and Internal Communication via Zavvy

Eine neue Trainingsroutine für die Führungskräfte bei Freeletics

Onboarding bei Storyblok - So schafft das People Team großartige Erfahrungen, während das Unternehmen von 33 auf 139 Mitarbeitende wächst.

Storyblok spart jede Woche 15 Stunden und hebt Remote-Onboarding auf die nächste Stufe.

Wie neue Mitarbeitende bei Alasco schneller und effektiver eingebunden werden. Case Study lesen.

Wie Alasco die Zeit bis zur Produktivität mit einem strukturierten, unterhaltsamen Onboarding halbiert hat.

The Competency-Based Performance Appraisal: Your Guide to Meaningful Reviews
13 minutes
How to Master Employee Performance Metrics to Turn Insights Into Income
14 minutes
A Complete Guide to 360 Evaluation Tools: Finding the Best One for You
11 minutes
Nie wieder schlechte Mitarbeiterleistung: Lernen Sie, wie man sie effektiv diagnostiziert und angeht
9 Minuten
Anonymes Mitarbeiter-Feedback: 5 Argumente dafür und 5 dagegen (mit Unternehmensbeispielen)
12 Minuten
Best Practices zur (360-Grad)-Leistungsbewertung - So holen Sie mehr raus
12 Minuten
Strength-Based Goals: How to Harness Employee Potential to Achieve Success
13 minutes
How to Conduct a Skills Gap Analysis: Steps, Best Practices, and a Template
13 minutes
6 Expert Ways to Integrate Performance Management and Talent Management
13 minutes
Anforderungsprofile: Mit der richtigen Rollenbeschreibung zu mehr Rollenklarheit und cleverer Personalentwicklung
14 Minuten
Leistungsziele vs. Entwicklungsziele: Unterschiede und wie man sie richtig nutzt
12 Minuten
Training vs. Entwicklung: Die zwei Seiten des nachhaltigen Mitarbeiterwachstums
7 Minuten
Making the Business Case for Data-Driven HR: 9 Steps to People Success
10 minutes
Top Leadership Books and Resources Recommended by Acting CEOs and Founders
11 minutes
How Do You Communicate Employee Engagement Report Results Effectively? (With Examples)
10 minutes
6 Best Practices zur HR-Automatisierung für moderne People Ops
8 Minuten
Wie Sie Ihre nächste Präsentation zur Personalstrategie meistern: Ein Leitfaden für HR-Führungskräfte (+ Vorlage)
9 Minuten
Vertrauen am Arbeitsplatz schaffen: 17 Wege, wie Sie heute beginnen können
12 Minuten
12 Top-HR-Tools für Kleinunternehmen
7 Minuten
47 Wege zur Steigerung des Engagements im Homeoffice (mit Beispielen und Tipps)
13 Minuten
Welches innovative Arbeitszeitmodell passt zu mir?
5 Minuten
15 Hybrid and Remote Work Trends You Cannot Afford to Ignore
12 minutes
How to Be a Great Remote Leader: Overcome Challenges and Inspire Your Team
11 minutes
33 Hybrid And Remote Work Statistics That Explain The Future Of Work
10 minutes
Company
AboutImprintContactPrivacyGDPR & SecurityJobsUser loginLinkedIn icon
Linkedin
Product
OnboardingPreboardingDevelopmentCareer PathwaysFeedbackTrainingPerformanceOnboarding WorkflowsSkills MatrixAnonymous Feedback
Resources
Case StudiesBlogDownloads11 Onboarding TemplatesLeadership Competency ModelCompetency Matrix TemplatePress
The latest insights & best practices on L&D and employee experience - delivered right to your inbox.
One more step - We have sent you an email!
Please confirm your address by clicking the link in there.
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Sign up for our newsletter
Unternehmen
ImpressumKontaktPrivatssphäre
Ressourcen
Case StudiesBlog
Folgen Sie uns
LinkedIn icon
Linkedin
Erhalten Sie die neuesten Insights und Best Practices zu Personalentwicklung direkt in Ihr Postfach.
One more step - We have sent you an email!
Please confirm your address by clicking the link in there.
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Zum Newsletter anmelden